248 C
HAPTER 8
One American's Story
Slavery and Abolition
James Forten’s great-grandfather had been brought from
Africa to the American colonies in chains, but James was born
free. In 1781, the 15-year-old James went to sea to fight for
American independence. Captured by the British and offered
passage to England, the patriotic youth refused, saying, “I am
here a prisoner for the liberties of my country. I never, NEVER
shall prove a traitor to her interests.”
By the 1830s Forten had become a wealthy sailmaker in
Philadelphia, with a fortune rumored to exceed $100,000.
Though some people argued that free blacks should return to
Africa, Forten disagreed and responded with sarcasm.
A PERSONAL VOICE JAMES FORTEN
Here I have dwelt until I am nearly sixty years of age, and have brought up and
educated a family. . . . Yet some ingenious gentlemen have recently discovered that
I am still an African; that a continent three thousand miles, and more, from the
place where I was born, is my native country. And I am advised to go home. . . .
Perhaps if I should only be set on the shore of that distant land, I should recognize
all I might see there, and run at once to the old hut where my forefathers lived a
hundred years ago.
—quoted in Forging Freedom: The Formation of Philadelphia’s Black Community 1720–1840
Forten’s unwavering belief that he was an American led him to oppose the effort
to resettle free blacks in Africa and also pushed him fervently to oppose slavery.
Abolitionists Speak Out
By the 1820s more than 100 antislavery societies were advocating for resettlement
of blacks in Africa—based on the belief that African Americans were an inferior
race that could not coexist with white society. Yet most free blacks considered
America their home, and only about 1,400 blacks emigrated to Africa between
Terms & Names
Terms & Names
MAIN IDEA
MAIN IDEA
WHY IT MATTERS NOW
WHY IT MATTERS NOW
abolition
William Lloyd
Garrison
emancipation
David Walker
Frederick
Douglass
Nat Turner
antebellum
gag rule
Slavery became an explosive
issue, as more Americans
joined reformers working to
put an end to it.
The people of the United States
continue to be challenged by
questions of economic and social
inequality.
James Forten, a
wealthy leader of
Philadelphia’s free
black community,
took an active
role in a variety of
political causes.
p0248-253aspe-0208s2 10/16/02 4:01 PM Page 248
Page 1 of 6
A
1820 and 1830. As one black pastor from New
York angrily proclaimed, “We are natives of
this country. We only ask that we be treated
as well as foreigners.”
African Americans increasingly were
joined by whites in public criticism of slavery.
White support for abolition, the call to outlaw slavery, was fueled by preachers
like Charles G. Finney, who termed slavery “a great national sin.”
WILLIAM LLOYD GARRISON
The most radical white abolitionist was an editor
named William Lloyd Garrison. Active in religious reform movements in
Massachusetts, Garrison started his own paper, The Liberator, in 1831 to deliver an
uncompromising message: immediate emancipation—the freeing of slaves,
with no payment to slaveholders.
A PERSONAL VOICE WILLIAM LLOYD GARRISON
[I]s there not cause for severity? I will be harsh as truth, and as uncompromis-
ing as justice. On this subject [immediate emancipation], I do not wish to think or
speak or write, with moderation. . . . I am in earnest—I will not equivocate—I will
not excuse—I will not retreat a single inch—AND I WILL BE HEARD.
—The Liberator
As white abolitionists began to respond to Garrison’s ideas, he founded the New
England Anti-Slavery Society in 1832, followed by the national American Anti-
Slavery Society a year later. Garrison enjoyed core black support; three out of four
early subscribers were African Americans. Whites who opposed abolition, however,
hated him. Some whites supported abolition but opposed Garrison when he attacked
churches and the government for failing to condemn slavery. Garrison alienated
whites even more when he associated with fiery abolitionist David Walker.
FREE BLACKS
In his Appeal to the Colored Citizens of the World, published in
1829, David Walker, a free black, advised blacks to fight for freedom rather than
to wait for slave owners to end slavery. He wrote, “The man who would not fight
. . . ought to be kept with all of his children or family, in slavery, or in chains, to
be butchered by his cruel enemies.”
Many free blacks, more willing to compromise than Walker, had joined one of
many antislavery societies active by the end of
the 1820s. In 1850, most of the 434,000 free
blacks in the South worked as day laborers, but
some held jobs as artisans. Northern free blacks
discovered that only the lowest-paying jobs were
open to them. Recalling his youth in Rhode
Island in the 1830s, William J. Brown wrote, “To
drive carriages, carry a market basket after the
boss, and brush his boots . . . was as high as a col-
ored man could rise.” Frederick Douglass, how-
ever, rose above such limitations.
FREDERICK DOUGLASS
Born into slavery in
1817, Frederick Douglass had been taught
to read and write by the wife of one of his own-
ers. Her husband ordered her to stop teaching
Douglass, however, because reading “would
forever unfit him to be a slave.” When
Douglass realized that knowledge could be his
“pathway from slavery to freedom,” he studied
even harder.
Reforming American Society 249
Frederick
Douglass, 1851
MAIN IDEA
MAIN IDEA
A
Synthesizing
What was
radical at the time
about Garrison’s
and Walker’s ideas
on abolition?
William Lloyd
Garrison's
newspaper, The
Liberator, bore
the motto: “Our
country is the
world—Our
countrymen are
all mankind.”
A. Answer
Garrison criticized
churches and the
government;
Walker advocat-
ed armed black
revolt.
p0248-253aspe-0208s2 10/16/02 4:01 PM Page 249
Page 2 of 6
250 C
HAPTER 8
C
MAIN IDEA
MAIN IDEA
B
Contrasting
How did the
various antislavery
groups differ in
approach?
MAIN IDEA
MAIN IDEA
C
Summarizing
Describe typical
work experiences
of rural Southern
slaves.
By 1838, Douglass held a skilled job as a ship caulker in Baltimore. He earned
the top wages in the yard but was not allowed to keep any of his earnings. After
a disagreement with his owner, Douglass decided to escape. Borrowing the iden-
tity of a free black sailor and carrying official papers, he reached New York and
tasted freedom for the first time.
Douglass became an eager reader of The Liberator, which, he said, “sent a thrill
of joy through my soul, such as I had never felt before.” When Garrison heard
him speak of his experiences, he was so impressed he sponsored Douglass as a lec-
turer for the American Anti-Slavery Society. A superb speaker, Douglass thrilled
huge audiences. “I appear before the immense assembly this evening as a thief
and a robber,” he would say. “I stole this head, these limbs, this body from my
master and ran off with them.” Hoping that abolition could be achieved through
political actions, Douglass broke with Garrison in 1847 and began his own anti-
slavery newspaper. He named it The North Star, after the star that guided runaway
slaves to freedom.
Life Under Slavery
After 1830, Americans hotly debated the issue of slavery, but
many African Americans still lived in bondage. In fact, the
population of slaves in America had nearly doubled in the
years between 1810 and 1830, growing from 1.2 million
to roughly 2 million.
The institution of slavery had changed substan-
tially since the 18th century. In those days, most
slaves had recently arrived from the Caribbean or
Africa and spoke one of several non-English lan-
guages. Most of these slaves worked on small farms
alongside people with whom they could not easily
communicate. By 1830, the majority had been born
in America and spoke enough English to be able to
communicate with other slaves. The rise of the plan-
tation in the mid-18th century brought further change
to the lives of the enslaved.
RURAL SLAVERY
On large plantations, men, women,
and even children toiled from dawn to dusk in the fields. The
whip of the overseer or slave driver compelled them to work
faster. Solomon Northup, who was born free and later enslaved,
recalled the never-ending labor.
A PERSONAL VOICE SOLOMON NORTHUP
The hands are required to be in the cotton field as soon as it is light in the morn-
ing, and, with the exception of ten or fifteen minutes, which is given them at noon
to swallow their allowance of cold bacon, they are not permitted to be a moment
idle until it is too dark to see, and when the moon is full, they often times labor till
the middle of the night. They do not dare to stop even at dinner time, nor return to
the quarters, however late it be, until the order to halt is given by the driver.
—Twelve Years a Slave
By 1850 most slaves lived on plantations or large farms that employed ten or
more slaves, but many lived on small farms, laboring beside their owners. Others
lived and worked in the cities.
URBAN SLAVERY
By the 1830s the promise of cotton wealth had lured many
Southern whites into farming, thus creating a shortage of white laborers for such
Planters’
children—like
Charlotte Helen
Middleton, shown
with her nurse
Lydia in 1857—
often were tended
by slaves who had
been forced to
give up their own
children.
B. Answer
Some thought
blacks should
be resettled in
Africa; others
believed aboli-
tion could be
achieved with-
out violence.
Still others
thought violence
would be neces-
sary to achieve
abolition.
C. Answer
Most worked
on plantations,
either in the
fields or indoors
as domestic
servants. Others
worked on
farms; a few
lived and
worked in cities.
B
p0248-253aspe-0208s2 10/16/02 4:01 PM Page 250
Page 3 of 6
industries as mining and lumber. As a result, a
demand arose for slaves as workers in mills and
on ships. Slaves who had developed specialized
skills on plantations were now in demand in
Southern cities. For example, slaves filled skilled
occupations such as blacksmithing or carpentry,
resulting in a new class of skilled black laborers.
Most slaves lived rurally—2.8 million in 1850,
compared with the 400,000 slaves living in
cities. However, enslaved blacks could hire
themselves out as artisans in Southern cities,
often more easily than free blacks in the North,
where racial discrimination prevailed.
Many enslaved women and children worked the same jobs as men in
Southern industry. Slave owners “hired out” their slaves to factory owners. In
return, the slave owners collected the pay of their slaves without having to super-
vise their activities. Thus, urban slaves spent more time beyond the watchful eye
of their slave owners. Frederick Douglass remarked on differences between rural
and urban slavery, noting that “a city slave is almost a freeman, compared with a
slave on the plantation. He is much better fed and clothed, and enjoys privileges
altogether unknown to the slave on the plantation.” Douglass also noted that “a
vestige of decency” in the cities limited the acts of “atrocious cruelty” to slaves
that were common on plantations.
Reforming American Society 251
Skillbuilder
Answers
1. Free African
Americans.
2. Plantations,
because that
was where
large groups
were found.
Southern Plantations
Plantations were virtually self-contained, self-sufficient
worlds over which owners ruled with absolute authority.
Owners established the boundaries that a slave could
not cross without punishment or death. But no bound-
ary protected a slave from the owner’s demands or
cruel treatment.
African Americans in the South, 1860
Sources: 1860 figures from Eighth Census of the United States;
Lewis C. Gray, History of Agriculture in the Southern United States.
Slaves owned in
groups of 10–99
(61%)
Free
African
Americans
(6%)
Slaves owned in
groups of 100 or more
(8%)
Slaves owned in
groups of 1–9
(25%)
SKILLBUILDER
Interpreting Graphs
1. According to the pie graph, what was the
smallest group of African Americans living in
the American South in 1860?
2. Under what conditions did 61% of slaves in
the South live? Explain.
Slave quarters, from a photograph taken around 1865
p0248-253aspe-0208s2 10/16/02 4:01 PM Page 251
Page 4 of 6
Still slaves never lost sight of their goal
of freedom. For some, it was time to take
more drastic and organized action.
NAT TURNER’S REBELLION
Nat Turner
was born into slavery in 1800 in South-
ampton County, Virginia. A gifted preacher,
Turner believed that he had been chosen to
lead his people out of bondage. In August,
1831, Turner judged an eclipse of the sun
to be a divine signal for action. With near-
ly 80 followers, Turner’s band attacked four
plantations and killed almost 60 white
inhabitants before being captured by state
and federal troops.
Though Turner himself hid out for sev-
eral weeks, eventually he was captured,
tried, and hanged. In the retaliation that
followed, whites killed as many as 200 blacks—many of them innocent of any
connection with the uprising. Turner’s bloody rebellion strengthened the resolve
of Southern whites to defend slavery and to control their slaves.
Slave Owners Defend Slavery
In some states, in the aftermath of the Turner rebellion, people argued that the
only way to prevent further slave revolts was through emancipation. Others, how-
ever, chose to tighten restrictions on all African Americans.
VIRGINIA DEBATE
Virginia governor John Floyd wrote of his wish for a “law . . .
gradually abolishing slavery in this State.” By January 1832 the state legislature
was hotly debating that very prospect. “Nothing else could have prompted [the
discussions],” reported the Richmond Enquirer, “but the bloody massacre [Turner’s
Rebellion] in the month of August.”
The debate over the future of slavery in Virginia result-
ed in a motion for abolition in the state legislature. The
motion lost by a 73 to 58 vote, primarily because the state
legislature was balanced toward eastern slaveholders rather
than non-slaveholders in the western part of the state. That
loss closed the debate on slavery in the antebellum (pre-
Civil War) South.
BACKLASH FROM REVOLTS
In addition to forcing the
Virginia debate, whites’ fear of future slave revolts had
another important effect. Most slave owners believed that
education and privilege inspired revolt. Thus, many slave
owners pushed their state legislatures to further tighten con-
trols on African Americans. These controls became known
as slave codes.
In 1833, for example, Alabama forbade free and
enslaved blacks from preaching the gospel unless
“respectable” slaveholders were present. Georgia followed
suit. In 1835 North Carolina became the last Southern
state to deny the vote to free blacks. In some states, free
blacks lost the right to own guns, purchase alcohol, assem-
ble in public, and testify in court. In some Southern cities,
African Americans could no longer own property, learn to
252 C
HAPTER 8
D
Artist Felix Darley
completed this
tinted drawing in
1863 for a history
book. Nat Turner is
shown (standing)
preaching to his
followers.
S
P
O
T
L
I
G
H
T
S
P
O
T
L
I
G
H
T
HISTORICAL
HISTORICAL
SLAVE REVOLTS
Armed rebellion was an extreme
form of resistance to slavery.
Nat Turner’s 1831 rebellion was
merely the most recent example
of slave desperation.
In 1811, more than 300 slaves
had rebelled in Louisiana and
marched on New Orleans with
spikes and axes before a well-
trained militia with firearms
stopped them. Gabriel Prosser
had hatched a plot to take over
Richmond in 1800, and Denmark
Vesey had led a conspiracy to
control Charleston in 1822. Both
of these conspiracies were
thwarted by the authorities
before larger rebellions occurred.
MAIN IDEA
MAIN IDEA
D
Analyzing
Effects
How did
Turner’s revolt
harden Southern
white attitudes
about basic
liberties for
blacks?
D. Answer
The rebellion
was bloody and
frightened slave
owners. Many
Southern whites
believed that
the only way to
prevent such
revolts was to
eliminate by law
any personal
liberties for
slaves.
p0248-253aspe-0208s2 10/16/02 4:01 PM Page 252
Page 5 of 6
MAIN IDEA
2. TAKING NOTES
In a two-column chart, list the major
antislavery and proslavery actions
that occurred from 1820 to 1850.
Which activity do you think was
most effective? Explain.
CRITICAL THINKING
3. SYNTHESIZING
Which do you think was a more
effective strategy for achieving the
abolitionists’ goal of eliminating
slavery—violence or nonviolence?
Why? Think About:
Garrison’s and Walker’s remarks
Frederick Douglass’s views
Southerners’ reactions to Nat
Turner’s rebellion
4. SUMMARIZING
What arguments did Southern
proslavery whites employ to defend
slavery?
5. COMPARING
Compare the similarities and
differences between the situations
of free blacks in the North and
slaves in the South.
Reforming American Society 253
read and write, or work independently as carpenters or
blacksmiths.
PROSLAVERY DEFENSES
Some proslavery advocates
used the Bible to defend slavery, citing passages that coun-
seled servants to obey their masters. Slavery, Southern slave
owners argued, actually benefited blacks by making them
part of a prosperous and Christian civilization. Even
Southern white Christian ministers gradually shifted
toward accepting slavery during this period. Some had
attacked slavery in the early 1800s, but by the 1830s most
white ministers in the South agreed that slavery and
Christianity could coexist.
Slave owners invented the myth of the happy slave, a
cherished addition to the plantation family. To this image
they contrasted that of the Northern wage slave, a wage-
earning immigrant or free black who worked for pennies in
dark and airless factories. George Fitzhugh, a Virginia slave
owner, argued that whereas Northern mill owners fired
their workers when they became too old or sick to work,
Southerners cared for their slaves for a lifetime.
Abolitionists, however, continued to campaign for
emancipation. One maneuver was to swamp Congress with
petitions to end slavery in the District of Columbia.
Southern representatives countered in 1836 by securing the
adoption of a gag rule, a rule limiting or preventing
debate on an issue—which meant that citizens submitting
petitions were deprived of their right to have them heard.
The gag rule eventually was repealed in 1844.
Nevertheless, as abolitionists’ efforts intensified during
the 1850s, some turned to violence. The more clear-sighted
began to sound the alarm: this turmoil over slavery would
lead to a divided nation.
W
O
R
L
D
S
T
A
G
E
W
O
R
L
D
S
T
A
G
E
SLAVERY IN THE AMERICAS
Slaves formed a smaller portion
of the total population in the
American South than in the
Caribbean and in Brazil. African
slaves formed almost 80 percent
of the population of Jamaica, a
colony of Great Britain. Because
so many slaves in that colony
died, slave owners demanded a
constant renewal of their supply
from Africa, thus maintaining the
Atlantic slave trade. Slavery ended
in the British empire in 1833.
Brazil also had a large propor-
tion of slaves. During the 1800s
slaves made up more than half
the colonial population of Brazil
and worked primarily on large cof-
fee plantations. Slavery was abol-
ished in Brazil in 1888.
ATLANTIC
OCEAN
PACIFIC
OCEAN
Caribbean Sea
JAMAICA
BRAZIL
SOUTH
AMERICA
abolition
William Lloyd Garrison
emancipation
David Walker
Frederick Douglass
Nat Turner
antebellum
gag rule
1. TERMS & NAMES For each term or name, write a sentence explaining its significance.
Antislavery
Actions
Proslavery
Actions
p0248-253aspe-0208s2 10/16/02 4:01 PM Page 253
Page 6 of 6